Here's
a group of sisters from Minami ke:
And a
group of friends from The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya:
And a
pair of brothers from Mawaru Penguindrum:
What
do these (and other) characters have in common?
- Big eyes
- Small mouths when closed, big when open
- Hair shades of browns and blacks
- Light skin colors
- Less noticeable noses
Do anime characters represent the
“standard of beauty?”
Anime
characters do tend to have very exaggerated characteristics (huge
eyes, for example), like any drawing or cartoon might. The aspect of
big eyes is indeed a characteristic that Asian cultures tend to find
favorable, as well as lighter skin, and they do indeed tend to have
less pronounced noses than many other ethnicities in the world,
however, I don't think that they really represent what the Japanese
“standard of attractiveness” is. In America, almost all of the
people on TV and any sort of media are only those that our society
has deemed “beautiful”. There is a huge pressure on our society
that if we don't look like the models then we aren't beautiful.
However, in Japan there is a different approach. There is not a big
push to look like the supermodels. Instead, the goal is to look
put-together and have a more natural beauty. They focus on fixing
themselves up and being healthy (like having clear and smooth skin,
long silky hair, etc), instead of focusing on whether or not their
hips are too big or their knees too knobby.
A big
question that I sometimes get when Americans see anime for the first
time is “Why do the characters look white?”
And it has baffled me too, once I started to really think about it.
However, in trying to figure it out the answer was actually insanely
simple. We just couldn't see it until we thought about it from
another point of view. Say I draw a stick figure. What race and
gender do you assume it is? I'm guessing most Americans would say a
white male. How about a stick figure with an afro and a bow? A black
girl, right? For most Americans the “standard” is white. Once an
aspect is added is it obvious it is something else. That is the same
way for anime characters. Since they are drawn by Japanese people,
they are drawn like a “standard” Japanese person. There, everyone
just assumes them to be Japanese. Not until a big nose, blonde hair,
and blue eyes are added will they be seen as a white person. (See my post on foreigners!) How they act and their
surroundings are really the driving factor that they are indeed
Japanese, though (if anyone is in need of the persuasion). While a
character may have green hair, yellow eyes, and white skin they can
still be identified as Japanese by the way they take their shoes off
when entering a house or by reading a Japanese newspaper.
Language corner!
美人
- びじん
– bijin
Beautiful
person (usually a woman)
日本人
– にほんじん – nihonjin
Japanese
person
容姿
-
ようし
– youshi
(physical)
appearance (of a person); one's face and figure
i asked myself the same question too the first time i saw anime. as i kid i wondered for the longest time why there were white people in japanese cartoons, and got so confused over how everyone looked. you've made a great point. they're not representing another race, they're representing themselves, but being an outsider to that culture, it's easy to make assumptions and ask questions based on our own persepctive.
ReplyDeleteI was in the same boat myself. Eventually I kind of just brushed it off as me not understanding and never really thought about it again until now. I actually came up with the topic because my boyfriend had asked me the same question. I figured this was a great time to really find out why it was the case!
DeleteAnd I'm glad I did because it was a super interesting to think about things this way!
I like your title "big eyes, small mouths, and cary hair." just reading it, i can imagine girl characters in most of Japanese manga
ReplyDeleteThank you! I think those characteristics are pretty essential for any anime character! Haha.
DeleteInteresting post, I never really looked at it that way. Do you know the reasoning why Japanese people dress in that harajuku style?
ReplyDeleteWell. Harajuku is a shopping district that is known for selling fashionable and outlandish things. (I've been there, they have EVERYTHING!) But since it is such a popular place lots of people like to hang around there and show off their fashions as well. I wouldn't say that Harajuku really has a style. But the people that hang around there (and many other popular places) like to dress in the various trends that are popular like Lolita, Gyaru, etc. As for why that sort of clothing is popular is partly due to the whole pressure of uniformity in the country - sort of a rebellious aspect. But each subculture and subsequent trend I would say has varying reasons (sometimes rebelling against certain things, sometimes to simply stand out, etc). But this is not the majority of what people wear in Japan AT ALL. Japanese people still think that those styles are on the weird side.
DeleteWhat an insightful discussion of how a culture signifies the standard human appearance and identity.
ReplyDeleteYour example of the stick figure calls to mind the linguistic concept of "markedness" http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Markedness
The stick man on the men's room is unmarked, but the sign for the women's room has to be marked with a skirt.
Yes, that is very similar! And another very interesting interesting aspect of culture! Thanks for bringing it up, I had some fun reading up on it!
Delete